Best of Bay Shore, NY
The best restaurants, cafés, bars, shops and things to do in Bay Shore, NY — mapped and organized by category.
About Bay Shore
Bay Shore is a hamlet and census-designated place in the Town of Islip on Long Island's South Shore. It adjoins the Great South Bay, offering direct access to coastal waters. The community had a population of 29,244 at the time of the 2020 census.
📣 What's going on in Bay Shore
Nothing new in Bay Shore this week — be the first to post something!
Redefine Meals
Redefine Meals is a restaurant located at 526 East Main Street. It serves American, Italian, Mexican, and Asian cuisine.
View details →Best Hotels in Bay Shore
1 places · Where to stay, from budget-friendly to boutique.
Best Restaurants in Bay Shore
35 places · Where to eat, from neighborhood staples to standout kitchens.
-
Mustang's Restaurant and Fried Chicken
Mustang's Restaurant and Fried Chicken offers pizza at 3 Candlewood Road.
-
Redefine Meals
Redefine Meals is a restaurant located at 526 East Main Street. It serves American, Italian, Mexican, and Asian cuisine.
-
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails
The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails is located at 150 East Main Street.
-
Vinnie's Mulberry Street
Vinnie's Mulberry Street serves pizza at 42 West Main Street.
Best Cafés & Coffee in Bay Shore
5 places · Coffee shops, roasters and casual spots to linger.
-
Bay Shore Bean
Bay Shore Bean is a café located at 47 East Main Street, offering coffee shop services.
Best Bars & Nightlife in Bay Shore
6 places · Cocktail bars, pubs and where the night goes.
-
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar is located at 12 East Main Street, offering a grill‑focused menu in a bar setting.
-
Destination Unknown Beer Company
Destination Unknown Beer Company is a local bar offering a relaxed atmosphere for beer enthusiasts.
-
Kitty Mulligan's
Kitty Mulligan's is a bar that offers a relaxed atmosphere and a selection of drinks for patrons to enjoy.
Best Things to Do in Bay Shore
5 places · Museums, landmarks and the experiences worth your time.
-
Bay Shore Historical Society
The Bay Shore Historical Society is located at 22 Maple Avenue.
Best Shops in Bay Shore
4 places · Independent boutiques, bookstores and places to browse.
-
Garage Sale Store
Garage Sale Store offers a variety of used items for shoppers looking to find unique pieces at affordable prices.
Best Parks & Outdoors in Bay Shore
37 places · Green space, gardens and room to breathe.
-
Heckscher State Park
Heckscher State Park spans 1,657 acres on the shore of the Great South Bay at East Islip.
-
Bay Shore Memorial Park
Bay Shore Memorial Park offers a peaceful setting for reflection and remembrance.
-
Benton Park
Benton Park is a public park that provides open space for visitors to enjoy outdoor activities.
-
Birchwood Park
Birchwood Park offers a quiet retreat with well-maintained walking paths, shaded benches, and ample green space for picnics or relaxation.
-
Brookwood Hall Park
Brookwood Hall Park offers a peaceful setting for walks and family gatherings.
Nearby cities to explore
More guides within driving distance of Bay Shore.
- Islip, NY 1 places
- North Bay Shore, NY 3 places
- Bay Wood, NY 71 places
- East Islip, NY 2 places
- Babylon, NY 70 places
- Central Islip, NY 41 places
- Dix Hills, NY 17 places
- Hauppauge, NY 13 places