🏆
The 7 Best Pizza Places in Carteret
Every spot on this list is a real, independently listed Carteret business — ranked by how established and complete its listing is, never by ads. Tap any place for the full profile, map and hours.
-
2. Casa Nino's Pizza Bar
Casa Nino's Pizza Bar serves pizza in the Fresh Kills neighborhood.
-
3. Millie's of Staten Island
Millie's of Staten Island serves pizza in the Charleston neighborhood.
-
4. Mr. Pizza
Mr. Pizza is a pizza restaurant located in the neighborhood of New Springville.
-
5. Sunset Pizza Restaurant
Sunset Pizza Restaurant offers pizza in the Woodrow neighborhood.