The 8 Best Pizza Places in East Amherst
Every spot on this list is a real, independently listed East Amherst business — ranked by how established and complete its listing is, never by ads. Tap any place for the full profile, map and hours.
-
1. Bullseye Pizza
Bullseye Pizza is an American pizza restaurant located in Audubon.
-
2. John & Mary's
John & Mary's serves American pizza, burger, wings, sandwich, and more in the Audubon neighborhood.
-
4. Bocce Club Pizza
Bocce Club Pizza is a casual spot in North Forest Acres that serves pizza.
-
5. Bocce's Pizza
Bocce's Pizza is a pizza restaurant located in the North Forest Acres neighborhood.
-
6. Luigi's Pizza and Catering
Luigi's Pizza and Catering serves pizza in the North Forest Acres neighborhood.
-
7. Mattina's Pizzeria
Mattina's Pizzeria is a pizza restaurant located in the North Forest Acres neighborhood.
-
8. Amherst Pizza & Ale House
Amherst Pizza & Ale House is a pizza‑focused restaurant located in the Audubon neighborhood.