🏆
The 6 Best Italian Restaurants in East Setauket
Every spot on this list is a real, independently listed East Setauket business — ranked by how established and complete its listing is, never by ads. Tap any place for the full profile, map and hours.
-
1. Joey Z's
Joey Z's is a restaurant serving Greek, Italian, and seafood dishes at 217 Main Street.
-
2. Redefine Meals
Redefine Meals serves American, Mexican, Italian, and Asian cuisine at 5090 Nesconset Highway.
-
3. Pasta Pasta
Pasta Pasta is an Italian restaurant located at 234 East Main Street.
-
5. East Side Dining / Chávez Hall
East Side Dining / Chávez Hall offers a buffet that includes Mexican, Italian, and American dishes such as pizza, salad, and dessert.
-
6. SAC Food Court
SAC Food Court offers a variety of dishes including noodle, sandwich, stir fry, pizza, salad, bagel, omelette, italian, pasta, grill, soup, and barbecue.